Editing an existing photo
Ask Nano Banana to change the jacket, remove the person in the background or move the scene to dusk, and it usually leaves the rest of the photo untouched. GPT Image edits well too, and lets you paint the area to change, but Nano Banana is the more natural conversational editor.
edge: Nano Banana
Following a detailed brief
GPT Image is very good at doing exactly what a long prompt says: five objects in a particular arrangement, a specific label, a set colour palette. Nano Banana follows briefs well but takes more liberties with complex layouts.
edge: GPT Image
Text in images
Both render short text well. GPT Image is the more dependable for longer text such as menus, posters and diagrams. For type-led design, Ideogram is also worth a look.
edge: GPT Image
Resolution
Nano Banana offers 1K, 2K and 4K output. GPT Image makes square, landscape and portrait images at around 1–1.5 megapixels.
edge: Nano Banana
Cost per image
A 1K Nano Banana 2.1 image is 41 tokens, 2K 61 tokens and 4K 136 tokens; Nano Banana Pro is 161 tokens at 1K. A square GPT Image 2.5 image is 8 tokens at low quality, 64 tokens at medium and 254 tokens at high.
edge: Nano Banana